The Muslim Brotherhood

Just finished reading an excellent book by Lorenzo Vidino, ( Columbia Press, 2020), one that provides the best expose off the Muslim Brotherhood, its apparatus, methods of operation, and most importantly, the insidious danger this organization poses to Western civilization and culture. While there have a number of books and articles on the Muslim Brotherhood, few if any on the MB in the West and certainly none with the breadth and depth of this one. It is a very readable book, devoid of the usual cant and obscure post modernist writing featured so often these days in academia.


Vidino lays out the MB   threat in a scholarly but coherent style, ticking to the topic  and he  is also very even-handed in his treatment off the subject, critical of the right-wing propelling every incident involving Muslims into a apoplectic event, and particularly the Left who shut off any debate of Islam or Islamism ( political Islam) with cries of “Islamophobia,” regardless of the gravity of the subject  at hand.

Vidino approaches the issue by telling the story of those who live in the West, joined the  Muslim Brotherhood ((MB)  and why they left it, including the price they have to pay for doing so. As the author states there are many articles and books on the Muslim Brotherhood but almost none on the MB in the West.  I telling the story of these individuals as related to him in interviews, Vidino surfaces a number off rather startling facts that are often buried or ignored.

  1. The Muslim Brotherhood is a secret organization and goes to great pains to keep it so. In the West they cannot  exist in the open because their goal of a Shari’a state is totally incompatible with the Western concept of a liberal democracy. A further examination of this issue can be found in Bassam Tibi’s, The Shari’a State.  Tibi posits that ” Shri’atization does not constitute a part of Islamic faith, nor does it promote the democratization process.”
  2. MB eschews violence, not because they have moral objections, but because they see it as ineffective in bringing about the MB utopia. Therefore in the West, especially the United States, The Muslim Brotherhood  seeks power through grassroots, education, civic organizations, neighborhood associations, etc. As Vidino stated, the Brotherhood wants to engage with Western society but not be part of it. Their spiritual leader, Yusuf al Qaradawi constantly reminds the Brotherhood that  “it is the duty of the Islamic Movement not to leave these expatriates ( Muslims in the West) to be swept by the whirlpool of the materialistic trend that prevails in the West.” He has also encouraged Islamic ghettos for Western Muslims, such as the one found in Dearborn  Michigan, to avoid assimilation into Western culture.
  3. Perhaps most surprisingly the MB seeks identification and solidarity with the dominant elite strata of society. They are much more interested in cultivating sympathizers, and useful fools  among the  Western political class than ordinary Muslims in the West. While most Western Muslims, especially the Sunni, probably  sympathize with some of the MB agenda, few want to be part of it. In fact some leave the MB because of its manifestly racist attitude, and impenetrable political fabric. It is a Sunni Muslim exclusivist organization favoring Arab leadership at the top. The MB members see themselves as the gatekeepers to the entire Muslim community in the West.  As they tend to be well educated, speak English well, and present themselves well, the political class, in their quest to acquire “diversity” and maintain a political base in the Muslim community will use the MB members as the “go to” muslims whenever a “store front” Muslim is required. Ironically the politicos are the ones most likely to be used, not the MB members.
  4. Vidino carefully sketched the apparatus of the MB, dividing it into three parts; first are the purists, the leaders of the MB, usually with them for a longtime as dedicated workers, and doctrinaire in their beliefs.They are often intermarried and work together in legitimate businesses. Secondly there are the “Brotherhood spawns.” are above ground organizations established by the purists,  who deny any link to the MB but work in sync with their agenda, such as  Muslim student  organizations, etc. ( I would add the Council of American  Islamic relations to that category.)  Thirdly and most important, are the organizations in flunked by the MB. For instance the MB in the US identifies with “progressive” causes and inserts itself into “social justice” programs and activities.  ( The antics of the two Muslim members of the US congress are instructive in this regard. In my own experience I have found many ” interfaith” organizations as remarkably  tolerant of Islamist causes and demands.   I would distinctly ad the World Council of Churches to this category as they are always sympathetic to far left  and Islamist points of view. They turn a deaf ear to the plight of Christians  under Muslim rule and are extremely anti Israeli if not anti semitic.
  5.  There is much more to this book but these are some of the more salient issues that struck me as of vital importance. Its methods of gaining grassroots support seems as American as apple pie,  seemingly a version of Saul Alinsky’s “Rules for Radicals,” but much more destructive to the fabric of American life.  While the Islamic State and al Qaeda were getting all the headlines with a daily dose of their butchery, the athree piece suits of the MB brotherhood were gaining  adherents and power.

About Tex

Retired artillery colonel, many years in a number of positions in the Arab world. Graduate of the US Military Academy and the American University of Beirut. MA in Arab studies from the American University in Beirut along with 18 years as Middle East Seminar Director at the JFK Special Warfare Center and School, Served in Vietnam with 1st Inf Division, Assignments in Lebanon, Jordan and Egypt, plus service with Trucial Oman Scouts in the Persian Gulf. Traveled to every Arab country on the map including Iraq, Syria, Kuwait, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Tunisia, Algeria and Morocco.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to The Muslim Brotherhood

  1. shfranke says:

    Hi again, Tex.

    Fine post on a pertinent subject.

    Now back home (finally) after three weeks of hospitalization and convalescence due to that sudden bout of pneumonia (may you, yours, and your friends never encounter and undergo such an ordeal). Gradually, but definitely, improving over the next few weeks (although still moving slowly while being “buzzed out” with a prescribed batch of daily meds is no fun).

    FYI, just found two interesting and impressively-well-researched papers (one of them is a 393-page 2017 DSSN) about [1] the presence and activities of Soviet/Russian military advisors / trainers / technicians (system maintainers) resident in Iran during and since the reign of the Shah and [2] break-down and description of the current “Group of Russian military technical specialists in Syria.”

    Let me know if you receive my earlier direct email with its attached article about Russian “military interpreters?” If not, pleased to send it again.

    Today is Sunday, 26 April 2020.

    Best regards,


    San Pedro, California

Leave a Reply